Welcome to the first ever RC+ Stat Stumper! Since we cannot get enough of the Reds, we wanted to take a longtime ballpark tradition and give it a bit of a modern twist. The Scoreboard Stumper trivia question that takes place every home game is a great way to test your knowledge of baseball history and learn a little bit about the Reds as well. Every once in a while, we will post a similar type of question in the morning but with more of a focus on advanced metrics. We invite you to post your guesses in the comments (looking up the answer is cheating, what fun is that?).
The answers and winners will be revealed at the end of the day. Enjoy!
RC+ Stat Stumper #1
In the Statcast era (since 2015), Luis Castillo’s 0.273 wOBA allowed in 2019 ranks 5th among all Reds pitchers who faced at least 200 batters in a season. Who are the four pitchers that have had better seasons? For bonus points, which years did they outperform him?
This is tough. Gotta figure most are relievers. I’ll go with Johnny Cueto (2015), Raisel Iglesias (2017?), Amir Garrett (2019), and Jared Hughes (2018).
I don’t think Hughes strikeout rate is high enough.
Probably not, but a GB% that high (i.e., abnormally low launch angle) may help him squeeze in there.
Could be. His 2018 season was insane.
Cueto (2015), Chapman (2015), Iglesias (2017), and, uhhh, Michael Lorenzen (2016)?
I completely forgot about Chapman. I’d say he’s definitely one of the four.
Chapman in 2015
Iglesias twice. I will guess in 2016 and 2017
Cueto 2015
Jason Marquis (2015), Ross Ohlendorf (2016), Scott Feldman (2016) and David Holmberg (2015). Kevin Gregg (2015) probably had the wOBA, but not the 200 TBF.
Can confirm that even with the 200 batters faced, these players are not quite as good as Castillo
Here are my serious guesses. Cueto (2015) and Chapman (2015) seem almost certain. Iglesias (2017) is my third pick. For my last pick I’m going with Sonny Gray (2019). Gray has been ahead of Castillo most of the year in xwOBA, although Castillo may have slipped ahead now. Not sure if Gray shows up as well in wOBA, though. If not Gray, I’d go with Lorenzen (2016).
Fantastic question, Matt.
The moment you have all been waiting for. The first ever RC+ Stat Stumper winner is…a four-way tie! The correct answers:
1. Aroldis Chapman (0.247) – 2015
2. Jared Hughes (0.251) – 2018
3. Johnny Cueto (0.253) – 2015
4. Raisel Iglesias (0.256) – 2017
5. Luis Castillo (0.271 – dropped a bit after yesterday’s game) – 2019
Matt Wilkes missed Chapman while Eli J, Matt and Steve missed Jared Hughes. All four of you got three names their three years correct. Well done! Hope to see you again next week
Can’t believe I forgot Chapman ?♂️
Thanks, Matt!